Open letter to Mr. D. McGuinty

Mr. D. McGuinty 2 August 2007
Premier, Province of Ontario
Queens Park, Toronto

Dear Mr. McGuinty,

We, the Community Coalition Against Mining Uranium (CCAMU), are writing to request urgent action for the Ontario government to immediately stop uranium mining exploration and development in populated and environmentally sensitive areas of eastern Ontario.

A very large cross-section of eastern Ontario voters is extremely upset about the health and environmental hazards from uranium mining, which is considered a serious threat to current and future land use in our area. Thousands of eastern Ontario voters have already signed a petition.

A number of First Nations bands, who are upset about unwanted exploration on crown lands that are the subject of current land claims, have already taken physical action by blocking access by mining companies to their drilling sites. The local media has been covering this issue and, if it is not resolved quickly, it will soon explode onto the national scene this summer just before the October provincial election.

Following is a summary of the issues:

Over a hundred claims were staked by prospectors during 2005-2007 on about 30,000 acres of privately owned land and traditional territory of the Algonquin First Nations in the area east of Bon Echo provincial park and Crotch Lake, and near populated areas in North Frontenac and Lanark Highlands townships. Active exploration is currently in process, including ground and aerial surveys, road-building and initial excavation of drill sites. Drilling for core samples is scheduled to start in July-August 2007.

The Ontario Mining Act allows mining companies to conduct this prospecting and exploration activity without the knowledge or permission of property owners. There is also no requirement to notify or consult with the Crown when exploration takes place on unpatented Crown land. The exploration process itself can and has in the past done serious damage to property. The Ontario Mining Act allows excavation of thousands of tons of material in the exploration stage without environmental assessment and without a requirement to restore the land. The drilling process itself has risks … the planned depth of ~400 meters causes drill holes to become “wells”, which have to be filled to prevent upflow of contaminated water into the watershed. Drilling can also affect the stability of underground water aquifers that supply clean drinking water to wells in our area.

If exploration leads to an operational mine, ore is removed by strip-mining and shipped to a processing site, usually located as close as possible to the mine site. Uranium ore is crushed and leached using large quantities of water. The sludge or tailings, which still contains substantial quantities of radioactive material, are dumped into special tailings ponds. Reports in 1980 by the Ontario Environmental Assessment Board on Elliott Lake solved many of the problems, but cited significant residual risks in the area of long-term viability of these tailings ponds. More recently in 2003 and 2006, Cameco in northern Saskatchewan, which is the world’s largest uranium producer, suffered three major flood-related spills, in spite of new technologies in tailings pond management. In North Frontenac and Lanark, mining and processing of uranium ore is of special concern since a pond failure or accidental spill could cause toxins to flow into the Mississippi River watershed, thereby impacting tens of thousands of people in villages, towns and cities downstream, including the City of Ottawa.

There are hundreds of cases where mining companies have walked away from mines or processing facilities leaving a mess for the province to clean up. In December 2005, the Ontario Auditor General identified, out of 5400 abandoned mine sites in Ontario, at least 250 are “toxic waste dumps, leaching acidic, metals contaminated drainage into water-courses and aquifers”, and the AG strongly criticized the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines over their failure to protect the environment and Ontario taxpayers from the long-term impacts of mining.

In terms of documented health risks, the Ontario Workplace Safety and Insurance Act states: “primary cancers of the trachea, bronchus and lung among workers previously employed in uranium mining in Ontario are recognized as occupational diseases under the Workplace Safety & Insurance Act. They are both characteristic of uranium mining and result from exposure to ionizing radiation relating to the uranium mining industry”.

In relation to the government’s new Clean Air and Clean Water Act, we are concerned about the impact of potential uranium mining pollution on the water supply of hundreds of thousands of people in villages, towns and cities downstream on the Mississippi and Ottawa River systems. We do not want a repeat of Elliott Lake and other uranium mining disasters throughout the world. Airborne radioactive dust is carried by winds and will directly affect not only mine employees, but thousands of Ontario residents in Frontenac County, Lanark County, Tay Valleyand the City of Ottawa other area townships.

Farmers and rural businesses are very concerned about the effects of uranium mining on tourism, agriculture and other traditional rural businesses and land uses. Property owners have already suffered a negative impact on property values and in many cases have indefinitely delayed plans for property purchases or improvements at a substantial cost to local economies.

Nova Scotia has already enacted a province-wide moratorium on uranium mining due to serious health and environmental concerns and the poor environmental record of the mining companies. British Columbia is presently considering a similar moratorium. Nova Scotia’s moratorium was prompted by contamination from exploratory drilling.

The root of the problem is that the Ontario Mining Act is over 150 years old, and is long overdue for a major overhaul. Over the last few years, many proposals have been submitted to the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines (many at the request of the Ministry), but to date no substantive changes have been made to the Act. The unfairness of the current Mining Act and its extreme bias toward mining company rights over the rights of property owners and First Nations people is encouraging uranium mining exploration and development that is completely incompatible with current land use in our area.

We request that the Ontario government enact an immediate moratorium on uranium exploration, mining and processing in eastern Ontario and initiate a public review of Ontario’s Mining Act.



We would appreciate your support … please Email your position on our request for a moratorium to j.s.kittle@sympatico.ca or mail it to J.D.Kittle, PO Box 1050, Snow Road, ON, K0H 2R0. Thank you.



Please note that this letter is being sent to the following recipients:



Federal: Prime Minister of Canada, Federal Minister Indian Affairs and Northern Development, Minister Natural Resources, Minister Environment, MP Lanark-Frontenac-Lennox and Addington, Liberal Leader, Liberal Environment Critic, Liberal Indian Affairs Critic, Liberal Natural Resources Critic, NDP Leader, NDP Northern Development/Natural Resources Deputy Critic (Energy), NDP Aboriginal Peoples’ Affairs/West Coast Fisheries/NDP Deputy Whip, NDP Environment and National Parks Critic, PQ Leader, PQ Environment Critic, PQ Natural Resources Critic, Green Party Leader

First Nations: Chief AFN, Chief Ardoch Algonquin First Nation, Chief Shabot Obaadjiwan Algonquin First Nation

Provincial: Premier Ontario, Minister MNDM, Minister of the Environment, Minister of Natural Resources and Minister for Aboriginal Affairs, MPP Hastings-Frontenac-Lennox and Addington, Minister of Energy, Leader PC, PC MNDM Critic, PC Environment Critic, Leader NDP, NDP Environment Critic, NDP MNDM Critic, MPP Liberal Ottawa West-Nepean, Ontario Environment Commissioner, Auditor General of Ontario

Municipal: Mayor North Frontenac, Mayor Central Frontenac, Mayor South Frontenac, Mayor Lanark Highlands, Mayor Carleton Place, Mayor Mississippi Mills, Mayor Perth, Reeve Tay Valley, Reeve Beckwith, Mayor Drummond, Warden Lanark County, Mayor Ottawa

Associations & Individuals:

Lanark Landowners Association, Mississippi Valley Conservation Authority, Ontario Federation of Hunters and Anglers, Ducks Unlimited, Land O’Lakes Tourist Association, Lanark County Tourist Association, Buckshot Lake Cottage Association, Dalhousie Lake Cottage Association, Bedford Mining Alert, Mining Watch Canada, International Institute of Concern for Public Health, CCNR. Executive Director and Counsel of the Canadian Environmental Law Association, Mississippi Valley Field Naturalists, Ontario Nature, Mississippi Lakes Association, Tom Jackson, Buffy Ste. Marie, Graham Greene